Repair/Restoration Costs vs. Benefits

[blockislandguy]

I'm a newbie here so let me begin by apologizing for anything that might sound foolish. The SC 23 is a fantastic hull. Yet when I read the forums here I am struck by two thigs. Lots of guys here are into project boats with a low initial cost for the hull (maybe 5K or so) and then lots of sweat labor/equity. While I enjoy reading the ins and outs of the project boats, I don't think I either could or want to devote every weekend for a year to working in fibreglas doing $8 an hour grunt work. My 60 year old lungs spent a long year in VN and that was enough punishment. The second thing I notice (again, I'm a newbie) is that most SeaCraft of this vintage are going to need a new transom,new liner, new tank,new console, new gauges, and new stringers. Wow. (If this were a Land Rover, it would be called a body-off-frame restoration but if the Rover needed a new frame, as the SC might need new stringers, it would be called maybe a "frame up restoration"!)

What's the cost of this massive restoration? The real cost? Well, lets see. The hull, an engine, gauges, panel, tank, etc. all can add up. The $8 buck an hour free labor can take a year out of your life when you could be fishing, jogging, drinking beer or doing any number of life's simple pleasures.

Now, and here comes the real difficult part, compare whatever figure you came up with with the price of , say, a used 26' Edgewater. I (think) I see them for the mid-30s here in New England with admittedly a pair of two stroke engines but with only moderate hours. What is an impeccably restored SC 23 worth after all this work? IMHO maybe mid-30's.

YMMV

[RS]

I think you are confusing "some" for "most" in your conclusions. My experience looking at 30+ boats from the 70s is that work on transoms is common. Often there are soft spots on the floors too. Rarely would it need the rest of the things you've mentioned, though many may elect to get guages and consoles. I have not run into any personally that needed stringers or new liners. Not to say that "some" don't go through that, but it's certainly not "most."

Also, $8 an hour for glass work? Not anywhere in New England, try $30 to $60.

FWIW, I have under $20K into my 20 which included a 1.5 yr old Honda with 50 hours, 6 month old 5000# aluminum trailer, new transom, new gelcoat on hull and gunwale cap and numerous minor glass repairs inside, new flush mount hardware all around and more.
All I did was rewire the boat and installed the flush hardware. I think is was worth it.

[blockislandguy]

Thanks for the thoughts. In an effort to keep the cost down and yet speed up the work, what about using a body shop for some of the work? Would they be less expensive yet more professional than a boat yard? Here in the Northeast bodyshops get a labor rate about half that of a boat yard and are used to cranking things out quickly. Just a thought.

[RS]

BIG, Do you have a boat you're thinking of, or are you testing the waters? There are some independent glass guys in RI that are good and more reasonable than going to a boat yard per se.

[warthog5]

BlockIslandGuy I don't think you will find anyone here that will disagree with me on this. "It's a labor of love". It's not for everyone that's for sure. No one is in it to make money on their own boat.

[FELLOW-SHIP]

To do a project boat is for some people Something Special and for others it’s something Stupid. Truly It Is A Labor Of Love. And IT’S NOT CHEEP EVEN IF YOU DO IT YOUR SELF. And if you have someone else doing the job will you probably could buy a new boat for what it will cost to have someone else do it for ya.
Here’s the deal. What ever you think it will cost add 50 to 65% more to the cost and you got it right and what ever the length of time you think it will take double it and you are in the ball park and YOU BETTER LIKE DRINKING BEER OR YOUR NEVER GET DONE.
This is not a Logical Decision one makes, this is a Labor Of Love. People buy antique paintings for millions of $$$ and old cars for hundreds of thousands of $$$ we do boats for one of two reasons WE LOVE OUR SEACRAFTS, or GOD is punishing us with a lot of work for something we did to make him mad.
I put in over a year / 150 days of work and $32,000 to do my boat. If I were to think about this thing logically I could have bought a real good 5 year old boat that didn’t need anything done for approx the same amount of cash.
We Are One Sick Group Of People Here and if you hang around long enough you could get infected with a obsession that will never get better so you just got to give into it and do one your self. Bottom line is this there are a lot of guys here that could buy any boat they want others want a great boat for approx 50 cense on a buck but after you do one your self you will be more proud of your accomplishment and boat that if you got a new one of any boat manufacturer on the market. That why I really look at my boat as a
23’ SeaCraft CUSTOM BUILD BY KEN. I know that might not make any sense but it is true never the less.
FellowShip [img]/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img]

[ScottM]

There are guys that want a 23' anything, and then there are guys that want a 23' SeaCraft. Most of the guys on this site wanted an SC and did what they had to do to get one.

Many times I think of these boats just like the Bertram 31 guys think of theirs - a classic that is worthy of the time, money and effort they may need to become seaworthy again. Strick and Fellow-Ship hit the nail on the end when they said "labor of love".

[AJD414]

Just picked up my 79' Sceptre which is finally finished after being held hostage in a L.I. glass shop. At that time I agreed to a $10,000 cap on restoration, mostly cosmetic. During the project we discovered it needed a new fuel tank, and I added bottom paint w/boot stripe. After many months of delays, the boat was finally done. During the project, I paid them $10,000 as they went along, so I thought I'd owe around $1,200 on completion. When they handed me a bill for an additional $20,000, I thought it was a joke. P.S. I have spent 2 years and thousands in legal fees to recover my boat with a Federal Court order. Took my first ride about an hour ago, and suddenly I am grinning from ear to ear as though I won!! Lots of lessons here...but worth the pain. P.P.S. Does anyone have any idea as to replacing the pedestal helm chair with something else??

[blackfin29]

Aj

I realize you may not want to mention the name of the glass guy that did a number on you, but I am looking to get my transom redone on Long Island.....are there any particular towns I should avoid? Does anyone know a good glass shop on L.I. that is reasonable?

Thanks B.F.

[GradySailfish]

Blackfin, a good guy on LI is Pat Canary of Sandpiper Marine in East Rockaway/Oceanside. I don't have his number but I think infomrmation could help you. Although I've never had work done by him, I hear he's reasonable and excellent craftsmanship.